Acta Iuris Stetinensis

Previously: Zeszyty Naukowe. Roczniki Prawnicze


ISSN: 2083-4373     eISSN: 2545-3181    OAI    DOI: 10.18276/ais.2024.51-13
CC BY-SA   Open Access   DOAJ  ERIH PLUS

Issue archive / 5/2024 (51)
Pecunia otiosa and a risky business plan of Pliny the Younger (ep. 10.54)

Authors: Maciej Jońca ORCID
University of Lomza
Keywords: Pliny Trajan Roman economy municipal finances pecunia otiosa imperial financial policy forced loans mutuum
Whole issue publication date:2024-12
Page range:12 (229-240)
Cited-by (Crossref) ?:
Downloads ?: 29

Abstract

Two letters that have survived in a collection of correspondence between Pliny the Younger and Emperor Trajan constitute a fascinating source for the study of financial policies of the Roman state at the beginning of the second century AD. Pliny, as governor of the province of Bithynia and Pontus, sends a very unusual proposal to his emperor. He suggests that public money not invested in buying real estate be forcibly loaned to representatives of the local municipal elite (decurioni). Trajan, however, rejects this idea. So far, the imperial decision has been considered in legal terms (a loan is a contract and therefore both parties should reach an agreement that they intend to enter into it) and ethical terms (forcing citizens to take loans is not worthy of a just ruler). However, it turns out that Trajan may also have been motivated by other motives: he wanted to protect the market from being flooded with cheap money and inflation.
Download file

Article file

Bibliography

1.Andreau J., Banking and Business in the Roman World, Cambridge 2003.
2.Babusiaux U., Die Durchsetzung ökonomischer Interessen im klassischen römischen Zivilprozessess, in: Lo Cascio E., Mantovani D. (eds.), Diritto romano e economia. Due modi di pensare e organizzare il mondo (nei primi tre secoli dell’Impero), Pavia 2018.
3.Balbo M., Oblighi del padrone ed equipaggiamento del fittavolo nella rifflessione dei giuristi, in: Lo Cascio E., Mantovani D. (eds.), Diritto romano e economia. Due modi di pensare e organizzare il mondo (nei primi tre secoli dell’Impero), Pavia 2018.
4.Bracci F., Plinio il Giovane. Epistole. Libro X. Introduzione, traduzione e commento, Pisa 2011.
5.Burton G.P., The Roman Imperial State, Provincial Governors and the Public Finances of Provincial Cities, 27 B.C.–A.D. 235, “Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte” 2004, No. 53(3).
6.Capogrossi Colognesi L., Diritto, società ed economia in Roma antica e i Romanisti del Novecento, in: Lo Cascio E., Mantovani D. (eds.), Diritto romano e economia. Due modi di pensare e organizzare il mondo (nei primi tre secoli dell’Impero), Pavia 2018.
7.Carleton Andrews A., Pliny the Younger, Conformist, “The Classical Journal” 1938, No. 34(3).
8.Dębiński A., Jońca M., Leraczyk I., Łuka A. (eds.), Pliniusz Młodszy. Korespondencja z cesarzem Trajanem, vol. II: Komentarz, Lublin 2017.
9.Duncan-Jones R., The Finances of the Younger Pliny, “Papers of the British School at Rome” 1965, No. 33.
10.Farnsworth R., Contextualizing the Pliny/Trajan Letters: A Case for Critiquing the (American) Myth of Deliberative Discourse in (Roman) Society, “Rhetoric Society Quarterly” 1996, No. 26(1).
11.Gibson R.K., Man of High Empire. The Life of Pliny the Younger, Oxford 2000.
12.Harter B., De otio – oder: die vielen Töchter der Muße. Ein semantischer Streifzug als literarische Spurensuche durch die römische Briefliteratur, in: F.C. Eickhoff (ed.), Muße und Rekursivität in der antiken Briefliteratur, Tübingen 2016.
13.Jones C.P., A New Commentary on the Letters of Pliny, “Phoenix” 1968, No. 22(2).
14.Jońca M., Łuka A., Problem podwójnego obywatelstwa egipskiego terapeuty Harpokrasa (Plin., Ep. 10,5; 6; 7; 10): tekst – tłumaczenie – komentarz, “Zeszyty Prawnicze” 2016, No. 16(2).
15.Jońca M., Pliny and the Christians. An Attempt at Evaluation, “Revue Cirkevniho Prava” 2020, No. 78(1).
16.Kaser M., Das römische Privatrecht, München 1971.
17.Levick B., Pliny in Bithynia and What Followed, “Greece & Rome” 1979, No. 26(2). Lo Cascio E., La storia economica: i principali orientamenti degli studi (XIX–XX secolo), in: Lo Cascio E., Mantovani D. (eds.), Diritto romano e economia. Due modi di pensare e organizzare il mondo (nei primi tre secoli dell’Impero), Pavia 2018.
18.Lo Cascio E., Mantovani D. (eds.), Diritto romano e economia. Due modi di pensare e organizzare il mondo (nei primi tre secoli dell’Impero), Pavia 2018.
19.Lovato A., Pretium e quanti ea res est nei giuristi: rapporto fra il prezzo di mercato e il calcolo giuridico, in: Lo Cascio E., Mantovani D. (eds.), Diritto romano e economia. Due modi di pensare e organizzare il mondo (nei primi tre secoli dell’Impero), Pavia 2018.
20.Maganzani L., Economia e diritto Romano (XIX–XXI sec.). Storie varie di convergenze parallele, in: Lo Cascio E., Mantovani D. (eds.), Diritto romano e economia. Due modi di pensare e organizzare il mondo (nei primi tre secoli dell’Impero), Pavia 2018.
21.Mommsen Th., Zur Lebensgeschichte des Jüngeren Plinius, “Hermes” 1869, No. 3(1). Noreña C.F., The Social Economy of Pliny’s Correspondence with Trajan, “The American Journal of Philology” 2007, No. 128(2).
22.Rockwell K., DIMIDIATE MENANDER, “The Classical Outlook” 1974, No. 52(1).
23.Rostovtzeff M., The Social and Economic History of the Roman Empire, vol. I, Oxford 1957.
24.Sherwin-White A.N., The Letters of Pliny. A Historical and Social Commentary, Oxford 1966.
25.Sherwin-White A.N., Trajan’s Replies to Pliny: Authorship and Necessity, “The Journal of Roman Studies” 1962, No. 52(1–2).
26.Storchi Marino A., Per un lessico dei comportamenti “economici”. La sfera dell’otium, in: Storchi Marino A. (ed.), Economia, amministrazione e fiscalità nel mondo romano. Ricerche lessicali, Bari 2004.
27.Syme R., The Imperial Finances under Domitian, Nerva and Trajan, “The Journal of Roman Studies” 1930, No. 20.
28.Verhagen H.L.E., Security and Credit in Roman Law: The Historical Evolution of Pignus and Hypotheca, Oxford 2022.
29.Vidman L., Einige Bemerkungen zu Trajans Stil, “Listy filologické” 1987, No. 110(2).
30.Wallace-Hadrill A., Civilis Princeps: Between Citizen and King, “The Journal of Roman Studies” 1982, No. 72.
31.Wilcken U., Plinius’ Reisen in Bithynien und Pontus, “Hermes” 1914, No. 49(1).
32.Wilcken U., Zu den Kaiserreskripten, “Hermes” 1920, No. 55(1).
33.Woolf G., Pliny/Trajan and the Poetics of Empire, “The Classical Philology” 2015, No. 110.