Colloquia Theologica Ottoniana

ISSN: 1731-0555     eISSN: 2353-2998    OAI    DOI: 10.18276/cto.2024.40-09
CC BY-SA   Open Access   DOAJ  ERIH PLUS

Issue archive / 40/2024
The Ideal of a Good Ruler in the Political Thought of the Count of Chambord

Authors: Adam Raszewski ORCID
Academy of Applied Sciences named after Father Jerzy Popiełuszko in Grudziądz | Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences
Keywords: legitimism God king France national unity
Whole issue publication date:2024-12-10
Page range:22 (169-190)
Cited-by (Crossref) ?:

Abstract

This article is devoted to the person of Henry Bourbon, Count of Chambord (1820–1883), a representative of the idea of legitimism and a supporter of limited Catholic monarchy. The study presents the ideal of the monarch as found in the sources left by the Count and the accounts of his contemporaries. The text contains the religious basis of Henry’s politics: the concept of a messenger anointed by Providence and sent with the intention of saving the political and moral order in France. It presents the indispensability of religious sanction for the rightful heir to the crown – a representative of tradition and legitimacy, to whom all absolutism is alien. It characterizes Henry’s attempt to unite compatriots divided by the French Revolution, republican and anti-royal currents. The article discusses selected ideas of the new state: legal egalitarianism and meritocracy. It presents Henry’s concept of closeness between the monarch and the affairs of his subjects, the unity of the throne, and the fate of his compatriots. The article reports his ideas of the character traits that should characterize a king: mercy, honour, and duty. It records the positions of selected contemporaries, both expressing appreciation for Henry’s idealism and criticizing his political ineffectiveness. It shows that Henry’s method of action was to study signs, trust in God’s promises, and hope for unity with his compatriots. The summary takes into account the lack of political agency of the French monarch by law and, at the same time, the Count’s specific attitude – waiting for a convenient moment to act. This ultimately did not bring him political success. A comparison is made of Henry’s vision of politics with the classical school, which is similar due to its communal nature and search for the general good.
Download file

Article file

Bibliography

1.[Anonymously], Address of the Count of Chambord to request that the representative of traditional monarchy return to France, beginning with the words: “Monseigneur, In the presence of current events”..., bmw, 1882.
2.A to M. Berryer, January 23, 1851.
3.A to M. de Belleval, February 6, 1853.
4.A to M. de Carayon, May 8, 1871.
5.A to Messieurs the deputies Berryer, Blin de Bourdon de Larcy, de la Rochejaquelein, and de Valmy, March 19, 1844.
6.A to Messieurs the members of the commission of Loire-Inferieure and Vendée, April 28, 1850.
7.A to Monsieur Benoist-d’Azy, November 16, 1849.
8.A to Monsieur de Fontaine, February 5, 1844.
9.A to Monsieur the Bishop of Arras, November 30, 1851.
10.A to Sir Georges Sinclair, January 12, 1855.
11.To Colonel d’Esclaibes, September 20, 1844.
12.To Count de Salvandy, March 17, 1851.
13.To Count Jules de Cosnac, September 4, 1844.
14.To Count Molé, December 26, 1850.
15.To Duke de Cars, March 26, 1849.
16.To Duke de Levis, June 16, 1856.
17.To Duke de Noailles, August 1848.
18.To Duke de Valmy, May 16, 1850.
19.To Marquis de Bausset, November 1, 1849.
20.To Marquis de Pastoret, October 18, 1846.
21.To Marquis de Dreux-Brézé, September 8, 1842.
22.To Viscount de Saint-Priest, January 22, 1848.
23.To the workers of Paris, August 25, 1849.
24.Bauquier H., Cavalier G., Numismatic History of Count de Chambord, Librairie ancienne Honoré Champion, Paris 1911.
25.Bernard G., A Bankruptcy of the ‘Res publica francia’. Henri, Count de Chambord, “Respublica Christiana” 2 (2009), pp. 77–84.
26.Blaze de Bury H., Count de Chambord. A Month in Venice, Imprimerie Dandey-Dupré, Paris 1850.
27.Boissonneau F., To Monseigneur the Count de Chambord, Imprimerie de la Guienne, Bordeaux 1875.
28.Castel G., Letter to Monseigneur the Count de Chambord, Imprimerie Théolier Frères, Saint-Etienne 1880.
29.Historical and Popular Song of Henry V, Duke of Bordeaux and Count de Chambord, Imprimerie de L. Prudhomme, Saint-Brieuc 1858.
30.Chaffanjon A. (ed.), Count de Chambord. Journal of Travel in the East 1861, Tallandier, Paris 1984.
31.Delorme P. (ed.), Henri Count de Chambord. Journal (1846–1883) – Unpublished Notebooks, F X DE GUIBERT, Paris 2009.
32.Desplanches S. (ed.), Henri Count de Chambord. Political Texts. Communication & Tradition, Paris 1995.
33.Fabry H., Simple Letter from a Republican to Count de Chambord, Imprimerie Laloux Fils et Guillot, Paris 1879.
34.Henry V Judged by Himself, Paris-Versailles 1871.
35.Henry V Painted by Himself 1842–1871, Typographie de Pierre Grollier, Montpellier 1871.
36.Jacquier B., Dauphinois Legitimism 1830–1870, Centre de recherche d’histoire économique, sociale et institutionnelle, Grenoble 1976.
37.The Life of Henry V (Count de Chambord) Told to Workers and Peasants (Propaganda Edition...) / by a Child of the People, Lagny 1875.
38.Letter from M. Count de Chambord and speech given by M. Berryer at the Legislative Assembly during the session of January 16, 1851, H. Simon-Dautreville, Paris 1851.
39.Letter from Monsieur Count de Chambord to Monsieur Chesnelong, explained by itself, November 21, 1873.
40.Letter from Monsieur Count de Chambord to Monsieur Count Albert de Mun, November 20, 1878.
41.Letter from Monsieur Count de Chambord, January 23, 1851.
42.Letter on the Agricultural Inquiry, March 1866.
43.The Manifestos of Count de Chambord (October 9, 1870, May 8 and July 5, 1871): followed by the assessments of the main newspapers in Paris, Librairie des Bibliophiles, Paris 1871. My Ideas / by Count de Chambord, Paris 1872.
44.Nouvion G. de., Landrodie E., Count de Chambord (1820–1883), Librairie Furne/Jouvet & Cie Editeurs, Paris 1884.
45.Regnault É., A Christian Prince. Henri of France, Count de Chambord, Imprimerie Saint-Augustin, Lille 1885.
46.Saujeon J., Alarm Cry Against Atheists and Free Thinkers. Popular Brochure Dedicated to Monseigneur Count de Chambord, Imprimerie Alcide Samie, Bordeaux 1881.