Acta Iuris Stetinensis

Previously: Zeszyty Naukowe. Roczniki Prawnicze

ISSN: 2083-4373     eISSN: 2545-3181    OAI    DOI: 10.18276/ais.2024.48-06
CC BY-SA   Open Access   DOAJ  ERIH PLUS

Issue archive / 2/2024 (48)
Human rights in India – theory and practice

Authors: Aleksandra Strączyńska ORCID
Uniwersytet Kardynała Stefana Wyszyńskiego w Warszawie
Keywords: India Hinduism human rights
Whole issue publication date:2024-06
Page range:15 (107-121)
Cited-by (Crossref) ?:
Downloads ?: 177

Abstract

The aim of this article is to point to human rights in India and to take up a discussion about them. It is an interdisciplinary work since it refers to cultural, religious and social determinants. Selected provisions of Indian law are analysed and then their functioning in day-to-day life is looked at. The leading thought of the article is that the law currently in force in India has features that are indispensable in a democratic rule of law, though theoretical assumptions do not match up with practice and enforcing law in India is not easy. Social attitudes cause various complications. For hundreds of years, citizens of India have lived in a different way, which is why it is difficult for them to find themselves by applying new principles where man’s personal dignity, a real foundation of fundamental rights, is key. The article’s assumption is also that a deep and permanent change in society requires time, because a change in the law does not always entail a change in behaviours and habits. This study primarily employs the method of interpretation of the law in force and a comparative analysis to show differences between legal assurances and reality. The article analyses the situation of Indian women, with a particular focus on surrogates, and emphasizes the problem of selective abortion. It describes certain elements of Hinduism, which (despite a legal ban) still function within the society and contribute to discrimination. The article also touches on poverty and access to public health protection. Unfortunately, to see the real effects in people’s approach, penalization of selected behaviours is not enough. Time to create a new, better reality is necessary most of all. The manifestations of violations of human rights shown in this paper will undoubtedly contribute to a better understanding of this important subject, which is still a timely international problem, though, naturally, depending on the place, varies in intensity and takes on different forms.
Download file

Article file

Bibliography

1.Ahmed–Ghosh H., Chattels of Society Domestic Violence in India, “Violence Against Women” January 2004, Vol. 10. no. 1.
2.Bankowicz B., Państwo świeckie, in: Marek Bankowicz (ed.), Słownik polityki, Warsaw, 1996.
3.Beteille A., The Idea of Natural Inequality and Other Essays, Delhi 1987.
4.Biblioteka Sejmowa, Konstytucja Republiki Indii, transl. J. Winczorek, Warsaw, 2020.
5.Bywalec G., Reformy ekonomiczne i polityczne a rozwój gospodarczy Indii (1991–2012), Łódź 2015.
6.Dumont L., Homo ierarchicus. System kastowy i jego implikacje, Kraków 2009.
7.Dumont L., Religion, Politics and History of India. Collected Papers on Indian Sociology, The Hague 1971.
8.Gaikwad S.L., Protective Discrimination Polity and Social Change. An Analytical Study of State Action on Scheduled Castes in Aurangabad City, Jaipur and New Delhi 1999.
9.Gupta A.R., Caste Hierarchy and Social Change. A Study of Myth and Reality, New Delhi 1984.
10.Hućko M., Selektywna aborcja a sytuacja państw azjatyckich – rozwój oraz konsekwencje zjawiska, “Wschodnioznawstwo” 2014, vol. 8.
11.Karp J., Notka redakcyjna, in: Biblioteka Sejmowa, Konstytucja Republiki Indii, transl. J. Winczorek, Warsaw 2020.
12.Kopyt E., Cywilizacja Zachodu a problemy postrzegania odmienności kulturowych, Toruń 2004.
13.Kudelska M., Hinduizm, Kraków 2006.
14.Maritain J., The Rights of Man and Natural Law, New York 1951.
15.Mirocha Ł., “Macierzyństwo zastępcze” w bieżącym orzecznictwie Europejskiego Trybunału Praw Człowieka w Strasburgu, “Prawo w Działaniu” 2018, No. 34.
16.Myrdal G., Przeciw nędzy na świecie, Warsaw 1975.
17.Nehru J., The Discovery of India, Delhi 1994.
18.Osiatyński W., Prawa człowieka i ich granice, Kraków 2011.
19.Paz O., Podpatrywanie Indii, Kraków 1997.
20.Pietrzak M., Państwo świeckie, in: E. Smoktunowicz (ed.), Wielka encyklopedia prawa, Białystok–Warsaw 2000.
21.Thayyil J., Jeeja M.C., Issues of Creating a New Madre of Doctors for Rural India, “International Journal of Medicine and Public Health” 2013, Vol. 3(1).
22.Tyloch W., Bogowie czterech stron świata, Łódź 1988.
23.Zajączkowski J., Indie w stosunkach międzynarodowych, Warsaw 2008.