Studia Administracyjne

Previously: Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Szczecińskiego. Studia Administracyjne


ISSN: 2080-5209     eISSN: 2353-284X    OAI    DOI: 10.18276/sa.2022.16-03
CC BY-SA   Open Access   ERIH PLUS

Issue archive / 2(16)|2022
Ocena dopuszczalności pomocy państwa dla inwestycji w sektorze energetycznym w świetle zasad ochrony środowiska. Refleksje związane z orzeczeniem TSUE w sprawie elektrowni jądrowej Hinkley Point C
(Assessment of the admissibility of State aid to energy sector investments in the light of environmental principles. Reflections on the CJEU ruling on the Hinkley Point C nuclear power plant)

Authors: Marcin Stoczkiewicz ORCID
ClientEarth
Keywords: state aid environmental principles energy investments nuclear energy
Data publikacji całości:2022-12-30
Page range:14 (29-42)
Klasyfikacja JEL: K23 K32
Cited-by (Crossref) ?:
Downloads ?: 267

Abstract

A discussion on State aid law and European Union environmental law most often boils down to the question of whether environmental aspects must or can be taken into account when assessing State aid for economic support of investments in projects with environmental impacts. This question has two parts. First, does the measure in question constitute State aid? Second, if the answer to the first question is positive, is the State aid measure in question compatible with the internal market? The consideration of environmental aspects may have important consequences for both questions. The object of this article is to try to find an answer to the questions (i) whether environmental aspects must, may or may not be part of the assessment of the question whether a support measure constitutes State aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union?, and (ii) whether environmental aspects must, may or may not form part of the assessment of the compatibility of a State aid measure with the internal market? The search for answers to these questions is preceded by a general characterisation of the relationship between competition law (including State aid law) and European Union environmental law. The aim of the research is to try to answer the above-mentioned questions. It is formulated on the basis of a legal analysis of the jurisprudence of the Court of Justice of the European Union and the decision-making practice of the European Commission in State aid cases.These studies lead to the following general conclusions: (I) environmental objectives cannot alter the concept of State aid (its definition) and therefore cannot be taken into account when assessing whether a measure constitutes State aid; (II) environmental principles and rules apply when assessing the compatibility of State aid with the internal market; (III) State aid that violates EU environmental rules cannot be considered compatible with the internal market.These conclusions also apply to aid to the energy sector, in particular to nuclear energy.
Download file

Article file

Bibliography

1.de Sadeleer N., EU Environmental Law and the Internal Market, Oxford University Press 2014.
2.de Sadeleer, Environmental Principles. From Political Slogans to Legal Rules, Oxford University Press 2005.
3.Hancher L., State aid, (w:) Ch. Jones (red.), EU Energy Law, Volume II, EU Competition Law and Energy Markets, Sweet & Maxwell UK, Leuven 2007.
4.Korzeniowski P., Zasady prawne ochrony środowiska, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego, Łódź 2010.
5.Krämer L., EU Environmental Law, 7th ed., Oxford University Press 2011.
6.Kutenicova E., Seinen, A.T., Environmental Aid, (w:) W. Mederer, N. Pesaresi, M. van Hoof (red.), EU Competition Law. Volume IV, State aid, Claeys & Casteels Publishing, Leuven 2008.
7.Macrory R. (red.), Principles of European Environmental Law, Europa Law Publishing, Groningen 2004.
8.Porzeżyńska M., Pomoc państwa na produkcję energii ze źródeł odnawialnych w prawie Unii Europejskiej, C.H. Beck, Warszawa 2020.
9.Quigley Q.C., European State Aid Law and Policy, 2nd ed., Hart Publishing, Oxford 2009.
10.Stoczkiewicz M., Environmental aspects of State aid for energy investment projects, (w:) B. Vanderheusen, L. Squintani, EU Environmental and Planning law Aspects of Large-Scale Projects, Intersentia, Cambridge–Antwerp–Portland 2016.
11.Stoczkiewicz M., Pomoc państwa dla przedsiębiorstw energetycznych w prawie Unii Europejskiej, Wolters Kluwer, Warszawa 2011.
12.Stoczkiewicz M., Śniegocki A. (red.), Subsidies: a driving force or obstruction for the Polish energy transition. Analysis of State aid for the power sector in Poland, ClientEarth, Warsaw 2020.
13.Stoczkiewicz M., The Polluter Pays Principle and State aid for Environmental Protection, Journal of European Environmental & Planning Law 2009, nr 2, s. 171–196.
14.Stoczkiewicz M., The Emission Trading Scheme in Polish Law: Selected Problems Related to the Scope of Derogation from the General Rule for Auctioning in Poland (November 19, 2011). Yearbook of Antitrust and Regulatory Studies 2011, nr 4(4), s. 96–113.
15.Szafrański A., Pomoc publiczna dla energetyki jądrowej – na przykładzie decyzji Komisji Europejskiej w sprawie elektrowni jądrowej Hinkley Point C w Wielkiej Brytanii, Forum Prawnicze 2016, nr 2(34), s. 18–32.
16.Van de Casteele, K., Hocine M., Favouring certain undertakings or the production of certain goods. Selectivity, (w:) G. Lo Schiavo, The General Court Reassess the British Aggregates Levy: Selective Advantages „Permeated” by an Exercise on the Actual Effects of Completion? European State Aid Law Quarterly 2013, nr 2, s. 383–390.